Practicing To Death



practicingtodeathA Kentucky high school football coach has been indicted in the death of a player who collapsed at practice and later died.  He was indicted for  reckless homicide  in the death of 15-year-old Max Gilpin, a sophomore offensive lineman who died three days after collapsing during a sweltering practice in Aug. 20.  If convicted, Stinson faces a maximum of five years in prison. This is thought to be the first time a coach has been charged with criminal conduct arising out of the death of a player on the practice field.

At first blush the would appear to be  a simple civil matter.  While criminal charges are uncommon in such occurrences civil negligence lawsuits are not.  School districts  get sued when these things happen.  Money damages are paid. People grieve and get on with their lives.  What sets the case apart?

Heat exhaustion is a known risk in high school athletic.  Tragedies do happen.  At what point does the civil liability become criminal conduct?  It appears that the parents were the driving force in this being presented to the grand jury.  Max Gilpin’s father in a joint family statement stated:

“… what we have learned about the coaches’ conduct at the football practice that led to Max’s collapse and death is inexcusable, as was the lack of urgency and the delay in seeking medical treatment after Max collapsed and never regained consciousness. We intend to closely monitor the prosecuting and expect everyone responsible for Max’s death to be held accountable.”

Here are the reported facts:

1.  Witnesses allegedly watched Stinson allegedly put players through running drills for almost 45 minutes and the running did not end until a player quit

2.  Witnesses reported that  when players asked for water, they were told no.

3.  Emergency medical services were not called until at least 17 minutes after Gilpin collapsed

Here is how the Kentucky Reckless Homicide Statute reads:

reckless homicide is when a person fails to perceive a substantial and unjustifiable risk that the result will occur”

Does denying someone water in a high exertion activity in 94 degree heat create a substantial and unjustifiable risk?   I am not a doctor but if I am sitting on the jury I would have to say yes.  Based the facts most likely presented to the grand jury they had no choice but to indict.  While  there will certainly be other evidence presented, based on what we know to date, the coach may very well be convicted if this is not plead out and the  jury follows the law. The last time I looked, “this is the way it has always been done“  was not a valid defense.  There is another perspective as well.  High school teachers are often considered “in loco parentis” ” which means “in the place of a parent”  A  high school football coach can be in “in loco parentis“  standing as well.  High schools often have the parents of children in athletics sign forms putting the coach in loco parentis if something happens to the child.  It is unclear if such a form was signed in this case.  This puts the coach to a much higher standard.  If a parent had denied water to his/her child and the child died you can bet the parent would be prosecuted.

Richard Warfield, a Dallas criminal attorney had this to say:

“Without knowing all the facts or circumstances surrounding this tragedy I cannot be certain if the Grand Jury erred.  However, I tend to agree that this will set a tremendous precedent.  No doubt word has already spread throughout the coaching world.  Coaches and schools will seek legal opinions, cautious lawyers will issue cautious recommendations and the trend will be to “water down” practices, making them less strenuous.  I don’t know how coaches can be sure a player is not “dogging” it or is faking.  Just like our schools have dumbed down their curricula, there will be pressure to dumb down football practices, or even practices in other difficult sports like lacrosse or wrestling.  This is what happens in an overly litigious society. “

This is a tough call.   Should not coaches who take charge of our children with our expectation that they will look out for their best interests in our absence must be held to a higher standard.  Is the punishment harsh?   As compared to a dead child?  While this is the first time a coach has been prosecuted it is not uncommon in criminal law for acts that are negligent as compared to intentional to be criminalized.  This case is not unusual in that regards.  While I feel for the coach  I see the parents point of view.

Comments

Powered by Facebook Comments

4 Comments For This Post

  1. RHM (1 comments.) Says:

    My initial impression when I heard about the story was that it was just another case of an overly litigious society. However, after learning that the coach allegedly denied water to the athletes I quickly changed my tune. That's not just horrendous judgment – it's abusive and ignorant. The military forces its people to drink water in hot climates during training. Are they wimps? Didn't think so.

    RHM's Recent post…Friday Morning Fix – January 23rd, 2009

  2. Joe (1 comments.) Says:

    Individuals who find themselves in criminal matters that involve death or violence need competant criminal defense attorneys. This case seems particularly rare in that coaches aren't usually held accountable for such things.

  3. Edward "Beep" Schuh Says:

    Brian, there is NO excuse for a coach who is not up to date with current medical standards. When I was in HS, we had similar situations were water was denied and players best interest went unheeded in the name of "toughness". Today, with what we know now, this coach is negligent in his responsibility to each and every player on that practice field. We have had way too many instances of players having life threatening injuries and deaths due to "old school" standards. I can remember being handed salt tabs before going on the field in HS and then not being provided water or a break in action for hours on end. I'm surprised more players didn't die. While this may not be a criminal matter, the civil ramifications of this case hopefully will cause more "red neck" coaches to think before they push a player to a point that I know they couldn't go themselves! Time to pay up big time, but this guy needs education, not incarceration!

    Edward "Beep" Schuh's Recent post…null

  4. Mark Moran (4 comments.) Says:

    Given the many, many other tragedies of this nature in recent years, including in the NFL, this ignorance is not merely inexcusable, but criminal. Denial of water does not make someone a better football player. There was an element of sadism involved here.

    Mark Moran's Recent post…http://www.findingdulcinea.com/guides/Travel/New-Jers...target=”_blank”>New Jersey Travel

Leave a Reply

CommentLuv badge

Follow Me



The Revolution Rant Radio Show

Newsletter

Sign up for The Revolution Rant! Stay up to date on the great guests and provocative topics on my weekly web-cast!
Viva la Revolucion!


powered by MailChimp!

Brian Cuban on Facebook

Related Sites

cipro hc generic form
ciprodex pregnancy
buy viagra without a prescription
order cialis on internet
i want a lumigan perscription
cialis by mail
next day viagra
cialis professional
ups of viagra
lumigan price singapore
doxycycline 100mg uses
overnight delivery of accutane
online pharmacy canada viagra
cipro hc otic contraindications
generic cialis canada
buy zithromax
purchase cialis next day delivery
cialis cost
lumigan with free dr consultation
how to get cialis in canada
purchase cheapest viagra
viagra in us
lumigan rebate coupon
viagra.com
ciprofloxacin dosage side effects
buy cheap cialis online uk
doxycycline 500
lumigan 10
purchase viagra
cialis online from canada
cialis purchasing online
online generic cialis 100 mg
free viagra samples
cheap generic india viagralevitra 20mg
cheapest viagra online
get cialis fast
doxycycline buy
viagra doses
cipro breastfeeding aap
usa viagra sales
buy doxycycline medication online
buy doxycycline malaria online
lumigan weight gain
lumigan alternatives
buy cialis canada
original viagra online
viagra legal in canada
viagra online without a prescription
doxycycline mechanism of action
buy cialis online best price
doxycycline malaria prophylaxis
buy viagra on line uk
buy doxycycline for malaria
legal viagra
lumigan drops 0.03
where can i get cialis
expired doxycycline
cialis free delivery
generic cialis from india
lumigan how supplied
best prices on brand viagra
viagra 25mg online
50mg generic viagra
cipro side effects fatigue
cheap cialis
buy doxycycline online in uk
viagra free pills
doxycycline in las vegas nevada usa
buy discount viagra
cheap viagra uk
cipro uses in std
ciprofloxacin hcl zofran
cialis discount code
buy doxycycline in canada
buy cialis online in australia
itching from doxycycline
lumigan overdose
zithromax uti
soft tab generic cialis online pharmacy
online order viagra overnight delivery
cialis price 100 mg
doxycycline hy
cipro address johannrsburg
doxycycline fetal effect
cipro xr iv dose
cialis canadian cost
i want a lumigan perscription
generic name for lumigan
generic viagra 10mg
viagra online wit
where can i buy real viagra
viagra sildenafil citrate
order cialis us
ehrlichia doxycycline puppies
cialis without prescription
viagra discount sale
doxycycline and lyme desease
original brand cialis
viagra side effects
cipro hc otic shelf life
accutane no script overnight
viagra shop
lumigan allergan
viagra fast delivery
lumigan without a perscription
doxycycline allergy test dose
zithromax sinusitis
doxycycline acne
cialis malaysia
cialis bye online
real viagra online
doxycycline xibrom
viagra 50mg online canada
accutane by mail order
cialis and ketoconazole
doxycycline hyclate capsules usp
lumigan ophthalmic solution
doxycycline will treat chlamydia
compare cialis prices
buy viagra in india
lumigan generic cheapest
canadian cialis with 2 free viagra
cialis canada illegal buy
doxycycline and diflucan together
doxycycline youtube
cialis tablets
viagra alternative
cheap generic viagra
canadian discount viagra online
safe site to buy cialis
cialis bye online
buy cialis online cheap
buy lumigan online without a perscription
lumigan label
canadian pharmacy viagra legal
doxycycline prescribing information
ciprofloxacin nsaid
buy cialis online china
canada healthcare viagra
cipro usage
lyme disease doxycycline dose pediatric
viagra subscription
generic viagra canadian
lumigan 0.03
purchase cialis overnight delivery
women viagra
doxycycline directions
levitra viagra cialis
viagra for women
cialis side effects
free cialis samples without prescription
cipro side effects tinnitus
zithromax uti
adoxa doxycycline
doxycycline dairy
buy real cialis online
cheap viagra in us
generic viagra usa
buy cialis online no prescription
usa viagra sales
cialis soft
doxycycline breast feeding
buy ciprofloxacin ear drops
lumigan kidney disease
cialis for daily use
cialis pills for sale
mrsa doxycycline
purchase lumigan cod cash delivery
buy doxycycline hyc
buy cialis once daily
t pallidum treponema doxycycline tetracycline
lumigan discount card
lumigan without a perscription
online lumigan no perscription
doxycycline urinary tract infection dosage
25 mg viagra canada
buy cialis without rx
viagra 100 mg
ciprofloxacin dosage gastroenteritis
lumigan coupons discounts
lumigan 0.3
doxycycline hyclate
viagra in india
buy cialis on
viagra canada generic
viagra cost
buy accutane online pharmacy in turkey
viagra online canada
cheapest viagra 50 mg online
herbal viagra
cialis iop
cipro prostatitis time
viagra no prescription
lumigan dosage form
generic propecia viagra
cheap viagra online without prescription
lumigan without a perscription overnight shipping
cheap viagra
doxycycline wiki
buy doxycycline online without script