Tag Archive | "dogfighting"

Michael Vick Was Justice By Example

Tags: , , , , ,

Michael Vick Was Justice By Example


vick_courthouse_320I was driving around Dallas listening to The Michael Irvin Show on 103.3 ESPN Radio.  For those who do not listen to sports talk radio or follow the NFL, Michael Irvin is a former wide receiver for the Dallas Cowboys and a member of the NFL Hall of Fame.  They were discussing the Michael Vick case.

The subject of the  show segment focused on Vick’s transfer to  Atlanta from Leavenworth Federal Penitentiary in preparation for his release to home confinement and eventual freedom.(In reality  it was a temporary stop and he is back at Leavenworth).  They covered the usual hot buttons such as his pending bankruptcy case and of course whether he will be reinstated to play in the NFL.  Vick’s civil attorney Peter Ginsburg was a guest, discussing Vick’s testimony in the bankruptcy case.

The discussion  turned to whether they thought Michael Vick’s sentence was fair.  Michael Irvin and his co-host thought Vick was treated unfairly as compared to sentences other defendants had received in similar circumstances.   Ginsburg  chose his words carefully,  simply agreeing that Vick received a harsher sentence then anyone else sentenced on similar charges. (I don’t know that to be true but will take his word for it)  Was it fair and appropriate that Vick be treated differently than others similarly situated?  I believe it was.  My rational is as follows.

When looking at crime and sentencing , our justice systems sets two distinctly different types of deterrent values. One  is the range of sentencing and discretion given juries and judges for classes of crimes that set social policy in the long term.  There is no need to set specific sentencing examples for these crimes as a means of social deterrence.  Such examples in themselves, taken alone,  would have little or no effect on crime deterrence moving forward.  Such crimes are so woven into society and occur with such frequency that unless we change our entire sentencing structure and philosophy to make everyone an example , singling one person out for a harsher sentence would have no social detterrent effect .  The sentence for these types of crimes  send a societal message but not a message directed at any one individual. The example is made is in the consistency of prosecution and sentencing.

As an example, Jim Leyritz is on trial for vehicular manslaughter. He was allegedly driving drunk, ran red light and killed a women.  If Jim were to be convicted there will be a range of sentencing.  Whether he gets the minimum or the maximum it will have no deterrent effect on the the next person to drink and get behind the wheel.  It is a sentence of social policy against drunk driving and and not individual deterrence.  No one is going to think about the Jim Leyritz case before they drink and drive.(except maybe Jim Leyritz)

There  is also the class of crimes in which  the range of sentencing allows for a direct message to be sent to a narrow class of people.  Crimes that may not occur on a repetitive level to a degree that it is a societal issue versus a regional or even local issue. Crimes we do not hear about and are not de-sensitized to on a societal level.  Crimes such as dogfighting.  For these crimes, when the opportunity presents itself, sentencing ranges speak to a specific opportunity to send a targeted message to the narrow class that may be engaging in such conduct.  The message that such conduct will not be tolerated with the opportunity for the message to actually be heard and heeded.  Without the opportunity to make an example and send such a message in high profile cases such as Michael Vick there would be no deterrent value at all  beyond the person sentenced in prosecution of individual cases.  No one would take notice.

We are not talking about Vick or others like him receiving a sentence so harsh/disproportionate as to the crime committed to be considered unconstitutional and “cruel and unusual” as in the case of Genarlow Wilson or Marcus Dixon.  For our justice system to work properly these constitutional types of  “example” sentences such as Vick received must be made when the opportunity presents itself.

For these reasons Michael Vick’s sentence was appropriate and “fair”.

Posted in Law and OrderComments (10)


Related Sites

cialis daily
online prescription propecia
canadian propecia rx
mexico propecia
cialis levitra sale viagra
buy viagra pills
get propecia online pharmacy
usa cialis
lowest price propecia best
should i chew cialis
purchase propecia
cialis low price
viagra prescription
what is cialis
cheap viagra
viagra perscription
cheap propecia 5mg
viagra dose
buying cialis
canada online pharmacy propecia
cialis canada
online propecia prescription
buy propecia uk
cheepest cialis
viagra cialis online sales
canadian viagra and healthcare
discount drug propecia
viagra overnight
buy propecia online prescription
buy mg propecia
order propecia pill
cheap online propecia
usa cialis
uk propecia sales
generic propecia viagra
search propecia
cialis price 100 mg
buy discount viagra
lowest propecia 1 mg
canadian drugs propecia
how much is viagra
price check 50mg viagra
levitra viagra
buy cialis once daily
indian cialis
canadian pharmacy viagra legal
buy fast propecia
viagra fast delivery
cheap viagra online
online drug sales cialis
viagra non prescription
cialis online without prescription
lowest-price propecia costs us
buy propecia online cheap pharmacy
purchase cialis us
buy cheapest propecia
5mg propecia
canada viagra
buy cheap uk viagra
us cialis
discount propecia online
pill decription of propecia
cialis usa
viagra professional
viagra en gel
viagra tablets sale
rx generic viagra
online propecia sales
cheap order prescription propecia
pill decription of propecia
cialis quick shipment
buy canada in propecia
brand viagra
canada online pharmacy propecia
viagra samples
lowest price propecia
effects of viagra
cialis for woman
pill price propecia
cialis endurance
best price on propecia
cialis soft
cialis fast delivery
viagra fast delivery
buy discount viagra
viagra free
buy propecia in the uk
cialis fast delivery
generic cialis for sale
buy viagra usa
best price on propecia
cialis overdose
hydrochlorothiazide cialis
online propecia sales
canada viagra generic
levitra viagra
real viagra online
us cialis
cialis and ketoconazole
viagra in india
cialis sales usa
viagra online deals
cialis buy on line
info viagra
viagra mexico
cialis canada
discount propecia propecia
cialis express delivery
how does viagra work
should i chew cialis
cheap viagra
sell viagra
cialis herbal
cialis buy overnight
cialis sales uk
canadian pharmacy viagra legal
buy viagra in canada
viagra online sales
canada viagra
buy viagra cialis levitra
cheap cialis pills
buy branded cialis
viagra in spain
cialis from mexico
brand name cialis overnight
generic propecia effective
viagra buy now
canadian generic viagra online
canadian generic viagra online
usa cialis sales
viagra in india
online viagra levitra cialis
cialis for women
viagra replacement
cialis next day
buy viagra line
levitra viagra online
cialis from mexico
cialis strenght mg
cialis overnight delivery
cialis samples
pfizer soft viagra
cialis prescription
how does viagra work
cialis buy on line
mexico propecia
cialis trazodone
viagra pill
cialis mastercard
cialis express delivery
viagra mexico
5 mg cialis
cialis 30 mg
best price generic propecia
uk propecia sales
viagra perscription
canadian drugs propecia
viagra 50 mg
online propecia uk
viagra discount sale
viagra generic canada
viagra overnight
combine cialis and levitra
buy propecia uk
cialis fast delivery usa
viagra canadian pharmacy dosage
cheap price viagra
drug hair loss propecia
generic levitra cialis
cialis levitra sales
viagra aus usa
viagra 100mg england
viagra generic
canadian pharmacy cialis
viagra discount sale
lowest price for propecia
buy generic viagra
bruising on cialis
online pharmacy propecia
buy generic cialis
brand viagra professional
search propecia
real cialis online
cheapest prices on propecia
canada viagra pharmacies scam
cialis philippines
online propecia prescription
purchase cialis us
viagra generic
cialis order
generic propecia sale
cheapest prices for viagra
best price propecia
online propecia uk
cialis and ketoconazole
viagra canadian pharmacy dosage
cialis sample
viagra buy
buy cialis canada
canada propecia prescription
cialis discount
get cialis
cheepest cialis
liquid propecia
usa cialis sales
buying cialis
mexico viagra
buy fast propecia
cheapest propecia sale uk
buy cialis canada
buying online propecia
cialis levitra
viagra prescription label
buy levitra online viagra
viagra vs levitra
real viagra pharmacy prescription
generic prescriptions propecia
purchase cialis
purchase cialis cheap
cheapest propecia prescription
cialis arterial fibrillation
cialis headaches
pill price propecia
best price for propecia
viagra dosage
cialis endurance
buy viagra usa
viagra gel
cialis philippines
viagra buy
viagra uit india
cialis tablets foreign
best prices viagra
chip cialis
cheap order prescription propecia
viagra generic canada
viagra tablet weight
cheapest prices on propecia
viagra dose
cialis profesional
online prescription propecia
professional cialis
viagra online deals
purchase cialis
herbal propecia
ordering propecia
cialis usa
sell viagra
get viagra fast
viagra 50 mg